Customer reviews for dogstag.co.uk

Customer reviews

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The tags have lasted longer than I expected. Great buy for the price. Would buy again.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 31/07/2021 by JIM P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 4 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Quality of the tag! Great value! Fast shipping! Very pleased!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 03/08/2021 by DAVE H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The tag is made from nice quality materials and engraving visible and done well.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 02/08/2021 by JULIA G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very pleased with the quality for the money spent, the way it was customized and delivered. I would gladly recommend.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 30/07/2021 by ALEXANDRA Y. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Customization is on point, exactly what I wanted it to be. Shipping was fast too.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 27/07/2021 by AMELIA K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  All relevant information fit on this tag. Engraving looks nice, several options for fonts. Looks durable, so far so good.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 29/07/2021 by ABIGAIL G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Beautiful, sturdy, and arrived quickly. Best quality indeed!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 02/08/2021 by SEAN M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I love my dog tag. It is very easy to read. Looks durable. Everything is amazing.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 01/08/2021 by YVONNE P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The customization for the dog tags was exactly as I requested. We're very happy with our new tags!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 29/07/2021 by ALICE M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Nice and small, durable, beautifully designed. I love it and would definitely recommend to others.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 30/07/2021 by TANYA D. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I loved it so much. It came in earlier then expected and looked amazing.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 31/07/2021 by KEVIN J. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  These tags are so perfect! They have all of our information just as we requested, the tags are sturdy, and durable. We are so happy with the outcome of our request!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 01/08/2021 by ALISON S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Text were easy to read, tag is durable, and so cute on our little man!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 03/08/2021 by TONY B. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  It arrived much earlier than expected and the quality is wonderful!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 29/07/2021 by ANTHONY C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  It is sturdy, affordable and it fits my dog well.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 27/07/2021 by JADE H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I love it! Especially for its price.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 01/08/2021 by EDWARD G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  These tags are nice and they seem sturdy.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 01/08/2021 by KEN R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Tags are very nice. I like the customization options available. Their tags are top quality and very reasonably priced. I do recommend these.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 27/07/2021 by ROXANNE D. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  We love our doggy and are glad to have a great tag for him.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 29/07/2021 by JAYDEN G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  This tag is great - good size, light weight without being flimsy and easy to read!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 31/07/2021 by ETHAN K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Exactly what we needed for new pup coming home. Thank you for getting it done and shipped so fast! The tags arrived before the puppy did, so it was perfect!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 27/07/2021 by LUCAS W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I was looking for a good basic collar tag for my dog. Good thing I found this one which was great and priced very affordably.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 02/08/2021 by JONATHAN D. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very pleased with dog tags purchase. Would recommend it to other dog owners.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 22/07/2021 by CONNOR S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 4 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  This was a great value because of the quality of the actual tag. Engraving looks beautiful.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 25/07/2021 by EMILY K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Great tags for the price. Received them quickly and they were personalized as ordered.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by ANTHONY S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Perfect tag. Delivered in a timely manner. Engraved with necessary info on both sides. Great job!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 22/07/2021 by HOLLIE F. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent dog tags. Sturdy. Thanks!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 26/07/2021 by HARRY H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Tag is really nice. Engraving was done well. I would highly recommend.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 20/07/2021 by CARRIE L. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love their options of fonts and design/model for customization. Tags were perfectly made from good quality materials.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by ETHAN L. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The product is high quality. It looks perfect! I would highly recommend it.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by THEO R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very classy looking dog tag. Well done!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by DENNIS E. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love the look and it’s nice and sturdy. Engraving will last!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by ROSS W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  What a great tag! Engraving still looks perfect 3 months after purchase.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by CHLOE P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  My new tag for my doggo arrived promptly and is very well made. It is sturdy and attractive.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by ROXANNE T. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  These tags ARE perfectly engraved and their font options are all pretty. .

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 21/07/2021 by LEE T. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I needed a nice clear readable tag for my ?? dog & this looks good and works great.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by JOEL S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The tags are absolutely beautiful, delivered quickly, and priced affordably. Ordered three and I love them!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 21/07/2021 by STEPHEN S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Liked the tag, also their engraving. Text is easily readable and has not faded.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 18/07/2021 by ROSS W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Bought the tag 3 years ago and she's wearing it up to this day. It's still in good condition and the engraving is perfectly legible. For this price, you can't go wrong. Thanks!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 24/07/2021 by SCARLETT W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Super fast shipping, very well made and soo cute! Very happy with my purchase. Love it! Well done.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 19/07/2021 by DALE M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Great quality tag - even after a month of wearing it, it shows no wear or tear!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by MOHAMMED R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Looks good on our doggo. Double sided engraving is nice.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by KIRSTY Y. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Hands down these tags are awesome. Compared to higher priced tags, these are more durable and beautiful. Definitely quality!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by TIFFANY G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I am very pleased with the tag itself and it seems to be holding up to the rough treatment my dog gives it. Great product indeed.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 23/07/2021 by HENRY W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  LOVE this tag! Very sturdy, easy to read & lightweight.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 25/07/2021 by HOLLIE W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Perfect dog tags. Customisation was perfect and it was delivered quickly. I can tell it's durable.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 16/07/2021 by JOANNE C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Really like this tag. Easy to read and looks very clean and stunning.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 15/07/2021 by CAROLINE C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 4 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  What a lovely engraved dog tags! Very useful.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 18/07/2021 by CHLOE W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 4 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  These tags are very sturdy!

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 17/07/2021 by IMOGEN W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Came quicker than expected and better quality tag than we expected.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 18/07/2021 by REBECCA H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I love this dog tag with the front and back information, excellent purchase for the price, you can't go wrong.

  Review of 01/10/2021, following an experience of 16/07/2021 by KIRSTEN C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love them

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 29/10/2020 by LEO G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Brilliant, thank you

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 31/10/2020 by MILLIE C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Collar fabulous very good quality and fits lovely.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 06/11/2020 by MICHAEL G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  The dog tag is great! It's cute and pretty, I love that you can choose shape, size and colour. And you can fit a lot of info on it as well. Very happy with it

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 08/11/2020 by ALEX C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Absolutely in love with them

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 30/10/2020 by BEN E. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very happy with the dog bone shaped tag we ordered for our German shepherd cross, she looks very smart with it on her collar!

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 02/11/2020 by VICKY M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  LOVE THE TAG AND THE COLOUR LOOKS REALLY NICE

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 27/10/2020 by KAREN C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Was very pleased with my dog tag..it really sutes me

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 07/11/2020 by GRANT P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love the tag I got for my wee frenchie Thor, such good quality and only took a couple days to come. Very impressed highly recommend

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 27/10/2020 by HEATHER Y. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Another satisfied customer. Quick delivery

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 01/11/2020 by EMILY W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very helpful and efficient

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 29/10/2020 by AVA T. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  It is very good thank you

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 02/11/2020 by ROSIE G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Great dog tag took a while to arrive but it was worth the wait.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 08/11/2020 by ELSIE H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very pleased with my purchase

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 26/10/2020 by PETE E. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent service! Excellent product! Would definitely order from dogstag again. Very pleased.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 26/10/2020 by LAYLA J. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love the tag I got for my wee frenchie Thor, such good quality and only took a couple days to come. Very impressed highly recommend

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 27/10/2020 by ALFIE M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very pleased with my purchase

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 26/10/2020 by CHARLES W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent product

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 02/11/2020 by OWEN B. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I absolutely love my dogs name tag. Its bright and bold.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 11/10/2020 by CARLIE S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Brilliant product,Brilliant service.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 04/10/2020 by RUBY W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent, very light, not clinking on the food bowls.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 16/10/2020 by PHOEBE K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Tag was beautiful. Company so helpful and made sure the tag was perfect before sending as i wanted it to say happy birthday as puppy was a surprise. Looks absolutely beautiful on little Olive. 5 stars!

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 16/10/2020 by CLAIRE C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  A beautiful tag! People are always telling me that they love my puppy's heart-shaped Swarovski crystal-encrusted tag, and ask me where I got it from.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 11/10/2020 by BRANDON P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Great tag for my little Coton de Tulear - Fred

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 18/10/2020 by VICKY T. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Received my dog tag, it's very lovely snd well made. Looks beautiful on my staff and matched her pink collar exactly. Received late but due to current situation couldn't be helped and company stayed in contact with me till it arrived. First class service :)

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 07/10/2020 by BRUCE C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Ordered a personalised bone dog tag. Ordering was easy through the website and product arrived quickly. The quality is great. My pup was intrigued to begin with and tried to chew it - there isn't even a mark! It's such good quality, very strong and sturdy. Definitely recommend.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 19/10/2020 by TARA L. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Brilliant item, nice selection of fonts, big enough too fit the information I wanted on it. Arrived in nice eye catching packaging. Highly recommend by from this company.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 16/10/2020 by TARA H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Lovely wee dog tags. I have an english springer spaniel and bought a medium sized tag in a bone shape. No complaints and it looks really sharp on him. The engraving is very legible incase he is ever lost. Also we live by the sea and it hasn't shown any noticeable rusting after a month of use.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 10/10/2020 by ISABEL R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Gift for my sisters new puppy. She was thrilled and looks great as star stands out well. Well made products.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 21/10/2020 by HENRY B. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Bought a pink bone shape tag with dimontes and couldn't be more pleased. only tiny negative is, when attaching the ring it slightly scratched as the ring is very tight, its not noticeable at all so would definitely recommend and buy again.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 20/10/2020 by SAMUEL E. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I love my tags, I ended up ordering 2. Great quality

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 14/10/2020 by KELLY K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I purchased two beautiful tags for my dog Dexter .They are very clear to read and a lovely bone shape .The tags took slightly longer than expected to arrive ,but the customer service team were friendly and helpful .well worth the wait .I would definitely recommend dogstag & I will be using them again .

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 23/10/2020 by ELLA E. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Perfect and robust for my energetic Doberman!

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 21/10/2020 by DAISY F. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Love the dogtag we purchased for Fergie..easy to order and delivery quick too..would highly reccomend

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 11/10/2020 by PAULINE M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  My tag arrived in perfect confition and with a beautiful package. I love it and I love how it looks in my dog Amber

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 07/10/2020 by ANNA R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent product

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 21/10/2020 by PATRICIA K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Great service

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 01/10/2020 by ALEXANDER C. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Very pleased with dog tags, great quality and look super on our dogs thank you

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 03/10/2020 by WAYNE R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Brilliant!! Great communication. Came quickly. Looks lovely on

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 30/09/2020 by TARA G. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Easy ordering and great product - loved the preview so you can see what the text will look like

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 28/09/2020 by LILY L. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Really pleased with the tag it was just what we wanted for new family member

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 24/09/2020 by PATRICIA W. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Really happy with the tags purchased. Good quality and very clear

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 01/10/2020 by COLIN D. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Solid id tag with clear writing..happy with purchase

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 25/09/2020 by LEO J. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Both tags were gifts for my families dog's and they both loved the font, colour and shape of the chosen tag i picked. If i had a dog myself i would choose this company and i will tell friends about it as well.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 24/09/2020 by CARLIE M. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Lovely pink tag for my dog and the engraving is top quality. Only thing I would say is that the large bone is smaller than I thought, looks little on my labs collar. Other than that perfect!

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 30/09/2020 by ALISON H. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Quality product, very smart, easily readable, and a great colour!

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 30/09/2020 by ALEXANDER S. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Excellent quality, speedy service. The tags seem durable with little sign of wear after good use on the collar.

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 23/09/2020 by MOLLY P. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  Looks good

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 03/10/2020 by HOLLY R. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

• 5 / 5

  

  Edit Flag

  I ordered some tags for my dog walking business. They were perfect for what I needed and arrived in good time

  Review of 18/11/2020, following an experience of 02/10/2020 by PATRICIA K. *

  *Pseudonymized data at the request of the author

Reviews displayed in chronological order